Scotland's 2014 independence referendum ended with the Yes campaign narrowing a thirty-point polling deficit before losing at the ballot box, and this film, based on GA Ponsonby's book of the same name, argues the BBC helped tip the result. Campaign figures, media insiders, and ordinary voters describe two years of coverage they say favored the No side: headlines they call misleading, airtime given disproportionately to pro-union voices, and BBC silence on scandals dogging the anti-independence campaign while Yes leaders faced what interviewees describe as manufactured character attacks. The BBC's own defense, that its reporting met strict impartiality standards, gets stated and then tested against the specific broadcasts the film lines up against it. Ponsonby and his interview subjects build their case scene by scene rather than through outside experts, treating each disputed segment as evidence in an ongoing argument about whether Britain's state broadcaster covered a national vote fairly or helped decide it.