
Cropsey
On Staten Island, generations of kids grew up warned about Cropsey, a figure said to snatch children and drag them into the abandoned tunnels of the old Willowbrook State School. Filmmakers Joshua Zeman and Barbara Brancaccio, who grew up hearing the legend themselves, start out tracing campfire folklore and end up reopening a real case: the 1987 disappearance of a girl with Down syndrome and the arrest of Andre Rand, a former Willowbrook orderly convicted of kidnapping. Interviews with local parents, retired detectives, and former Willowbrook staff lay out a string of child disappearances stretching back decades, while archival news footage and shots of Willowbrook's crumbling, overgrown wards supply the atmosphere the legend grew out of. Zeman and Brancaccio press Rand's case directly, weighing the circumstantial evidence against him next to the institution's own documented history of abuse and neglect. The film keeps shifting between true crime and myth, never fully resolving which one is driving the other, which is precisely its point.