
Going Beyond the Here and Now: Counterfactual Simulation in Human Cognition
Tobias Gerstenberg, Assistant Professor of Psychology at Stanford, argues that counterfactual thinking, imagining how events could have turned out differently, is central to human causal reasoning. He presents his counterfactual simulation model (CSM), which combines a generative mental model of the world, the ability to intervene on that model, and simulation of the consequences. Gerstenberg applies the model to physical scenes such as dynamic collisions, cases with multiple or omitted causes, and the stability of stacked objects, showing the model predicts people's causal judgments. He also uses eye-tracking data to show people spontaneously simulate counterfactual outcomes while watching events unfold. The talk extends to the psychological domain, covering how people judge whether an agent's action made a difference, whether one agent helped or hindered another, and how blame gets distributed across multiple agents in a joint outcome. The seminar is part of Stanford's ongoing speaker series on cognition.