
Observers, Alpha Parameters, and the Hartle-Hawking State
Daniel Harlow of MIT argues that the Hilbert space of quantum gravity in a closed universe has dimension one, a result reached recently from several independent directions, and examines a proposal to fix the problem by building the observer directly into the fundamental laws of physics. Speaking at the Institute for Advanced Study's workshop on Quantum Aspects of Black Holes and Spacetime, Harlow connects this observer-inclusion idea to the Hartle-Hawking no-boundary state and to the alpha parameters introduced by Coleman, Giddings, Strominger, Marolf, and Maxfield in earlier work on baby universes and wormholes. He closes by identifying a new tension between the gravitational path integral and the standard picture of the string theory landscape. The talk draws on research with Ying Zhao and assumes familiarity with semiclassical gravity, the gravitational path integral, and baby universe physics. It is a focused research seminar rather than an introductory lecture, aimed at physicists working on quantum gravity and holography.