
Oligarchs and Their Discontents
Melissa Lane, Class of 1943 Professor of Politics, examines how oligarchic factions seized and lost power within ancient popular regimes. The lecture, recorded at Barnard's Inn Hall for Gresham College, contrasts Rome's patrician-plebeian conflicts, including the secession of the plebs and Menenius Agrippa's body politic speech, with Athens's two oligarchic coups: the Council of 400 in 411 BCE and the Thirty Tyrants in 404 BCE. Lane traces how each takeover dismantled democratic institutions and how Athens restored itself afterward, including its amnesty settlement as a distinct path to accountability. She distinguishes an accommodation model of elite power from an irredentist, reactionary one, drawing on the anonymous Old Oligarch's account of Athenian politics. The lecture closes by drawing lines to modern cases, including Poland's post-populist politics, as instances of the enduring challenge of taming oligarchic power within democratic systems.