
Pictures from Afghanistan: Are we making the same mistakes?
Human rights lawyer Clive Stafford Smith draws on six recent trips to Afghanistan to argue that Western policy toward the country is repeating errors made in Vietnam and in the post-9/11 war on terror. Recorded at Gresham College's Bernard's Inn Hall, the lecture opens by questioning the dominant Western narrative and moves through comparisons with his own Guantanamo Bay work, the 45-year arc of Afghan conflict from empire to America's longest war, and the fallout of the 2021 withdrawal. He examines sanctions and frozen Afghan assets, the legal routes for reuniting abducted children with their families, and the case for aid, healthcare investment, and cultural exchange over continued isolation. Stafford Smith contends that roughly 80 percent of Afghanistan's population and leadership hold comparatively liberal values, and asks what legal and diplomatic lessons follow from that for building a world where individual rights and the rule of law prevail. The talk closes on the practical value of direct human contact in shaping policy.