
Safety Claims and Free Speech: Preemption and Defamation
Yale professor John Wargo examines how legal doctrines of preemption and defamation shape environmental and agricultural regulation, using three cases as evidence. Bates v. Dow involves peanut growers suing a pesticide maker over soil damage. The Alar case traces how environmental groups and media pressure led the EPA to ban a carcinogenic apple pesticide. The Texas Cattlemen's Association's lawsuit against Oprah Winfrey over her Mad Cow Disease coverage anchors the discussion of state veggie libel laws and their chilling effect on free speech. Wargo walks through the origins of these legal concepts and how they have been applied to protect, and sometimes suppress, public health and environmental reporting. Recorded for Yale's Environmental Politics and Law course, the lecture connects courtroom strategy to the broader question of who gets to speak publicly about product safety.