
That's Not Funny: The Ethics of Satire
Judith Hawley, Professor Emerita of Eighteenth-Century Literature at Royal Holloway, University of London, asks whether satire's old justification still holds: that it uses nasty means toward good ends, ridiculing targets to provoke reform. She traces the canonical model of satire before turning to the modern backlash, from the fatwa against Salman Rushdie to violent reactions over published cartoons, and compares free speech traditions in Europe and America. The lecture weighs arguments that satire shades into hate speech against defenses of its social function, then works through a detailed case study of Alexander Pope before addressing the distinction between punching up and punching down in a globalized media environment. Recorded at Bernard's Inn Hall, London, for Gresham College, the talk closes by framing satire as a defense against tyranny rather than mere cruelty. Hawley is currently completing a group biography of Pope, Swift, and the Scriblerus Club.