
The Battle Against the Underdetermination of Dark Energy
Pedro Ferreira, astrophysicist at the University of Oxford, argues that cosmological data cannot yet pin down the microphysical nature of dark energy, even as it refines how the universe's expansion is measured. Speaking at the Institute for Advanced Study and Princeton University joint astrophysics colloquium, he focuses on dynamical dark energy driven by a scalar field, weighing evidence for and against the idea. Ferreira contends that thawing quintessence models are unlikely to be correct, and that evidence instead points toward some form of non-minimal coupling between the scalar field and gravity, which brings its own set of theoretical problems. He walks through proposed loopholes around these difficulties and gives his assessment of where scalar field models of dark energy currently stand. The talk runs just under an hour and assumes familiarity with cosmology, aimed at researchers and advanced students following current debates in dark energy physics.