
The New Testament as History
Dale B. Martin, teaching Yale's Introduction to New Testament course, examines the historical-critical method through a concrete test case: the conflicting accounts of Paul's travels. He walks through the itinerary given in the Acts of the Apostles, then the different itinerary Paul himself gives in Galatians, including a Jerusalem meeting that Acts portrays as a major council but Galatians describes as a small, informal gathering. Martin shows how a historical-critical reading refuses to harmonize these discrepancies or take either text at face value, instead weighing which details are more plausible as history. The lecture moves through three segments, first the Acts account, then the Galatians account, then a direct comparison asking which version better withstands scrutiny. It is a methods lecture as much as a Paul lecture, showing students how biblical scholars adjudicate between competing ancient sources.