
Street Wars of Religion: Puritans and Arminians
Keith Wrightson, professor at Yale, traces the collapse of religious consensus in early Stuart England. Part of his course Early Modern England: Politics, Religion, and Society under the Tudors and Stuarts, this lecture opens with the 'Jacobethan consensus' of James I's reign, a broad Calvinist conformity that held the Church of England together. Wrightson shows how local Puritan activists pushed for godly discipline, with success depending on whether they could win over secular magistrates, producing uneven reformation across English communities. He then turns to the rise of Arminianism, an anti-Calvinist movement favoring ritual and clerical authority, and explains how Charles I's appointment of Arminians like William Laud to church leadership turned religious doctrine into a polarizing political weapon. The lecture runs in four chapters, ending with the consequences of this polarization for the growing tensions that would lead to civil war. Recorded in 2009 as part of Yale's Open Courses series.