LECTURES A GRATIS GLOBAL SERVICE
⌕ SEARCH GRATIS GLOBAL ↗
LECTURES
Reading Between the Lines, Part 1: Holistic Reading and the Unwritten Constitution
SOURCE: YOUTUBE · NO TRACKING UNTIL YOU PRESS PLAY · TROUBLE PLAYING? WATCH AT THE SOURCE ↗

Reading Between the Lines, Part 1: Holistic Reading and the Unwritten Constitution

24 MIN · EN · STATUS: [ STREAMING ]
RATE THIS
YALE · America's Unwritten Constitution with Akhil Reed Amar · LECTURE 2

Akhil Reed Amar, Yale Law School, opens his course on America's Unwritten Constitution by asking who presides at a vice president's own impeachment trial. Read literally, the text seems to let the vice president judge his own case, an outcome Amar shows cannot be right. He introduces holistic reading, the practice of interpreting the Constitution as a unified document rather than isolated clauses, and traces the underlying absurdity canon back to Blackstone, the eighteenth century's leading legal authority. The same logic explains why the chief justice, not the vice president, presides at presidential impeachment trials. Amar then turns to McCulloch v. Maryland, where John Marshall upheld a national bank despite the Constitution containing no explicit bank clause, reading the document in light of its purposes rather than its literal wording. The lecture runs twenty-four minutes and moves through chaptered segments from the impeachment puzzle to the McCulloch ruling.

At a glance

Lecture facts

Runtime compared with the other 331 Political Science lectures
Runtime24 m
Compared with Political ScienceShorter than 87%
This series

America's Unwritten Constitution with Akhil Reed Amar

Every lecture in order, sized by its length.

  • Earlier lectures
  • This lecture
  • Still to come
Lecture 1 of 280 m before this · 10 h 50 m in total

More from this course

12 LECTURES
Reading Between the Lines, Part 2: America's Unwritten Constitution

Reading Between the Lines, Part 2: America's Unwritten Constitution

YALE · 27 MIN
Heeding the Deed, Part 1

Heeding the Deed, Part 1

YALE · 23 MIN
Heeding the Deed, Part 2: America's Unwritten Constitution

Heeding the Deed, Part 2: America's Unwritten Constitution

YALE · 24 MIN
Hearing the People, Part 1: Unwritten Rights and the Ninth Amendment

Hearing the People, Part 1: Unwritten Rights and the Ninth Amendment

YALE · 27 MIN
Hearing the People, Part 2: America's Unwritten Constitution

Hearing the People, Part 2: America's Unwritten Constitution

YALE · 22 MIN
Confronting Modern Case Law, Part 1

Confronting Modern Case Law, Part 1

YALE · 31 MIN
Confronting Modern Case Law, Part 2

Confronting Modern Case Law, Part 2

YALE · 28 MIN
Putting Precedent in Its Place, Part 1

Putting Precedent in Its Place, Part 1

YALE · 26 MIN
Putting Precedent in Its Place, Part 2

Putting Precedent in Its Place, Part 2

YALE · 24 MIN
Honoring the Icons, Part 1: America's Unwritten Constitution

Honoring the Icons, Part 1: America's Unwritten Constitution

YALE · 28 MIN
Whose Constitution Do We Actually Live In? America's Unwritten Constitution

Whose Constitution Do We Actually Live In? America's Unwritten Constitution

YALE · 23 MIN
Remembering the Ladies, Part 1: America's Unwritten Constitution

Remembering the Ladies, Part 1: America's Unwritten Constitution

YALE · 23 MIN