
Appropriating Locke Today
Ian Shapiro continues his Yale course on the moral foundations of politics by turning to social contract theory, the last Enlightenment tradition the course takes up. He frames the challenge as secularizing Locke and reconciling his thought with the rejection of natural rights, which modern theorists address by replacing natural rights with Kant's categorical imperative and treating the social contract as a hypothetical thought experiment: what state, if any, would free individuals choose to create? Shapiro works through Robert Nozick's theory of a dominant protective association arising from voluntary mutual protection arrangements, explaining Nozick's argument that coercive force must be exercised as a monopoly and that no other natural monopoly exists, pushing a dominant association toward resembling a state. The lecture closes on the unresolved problem of how independents who refuse to join get incorporated. Chapters cover Nozick's biography, the Kant-Nozick account of liberty, and the state's evolution without rights violations.