
The Marxian Failure and Legacy
Ian Shapiro continues his Yale course Moral Foundations of Politics with a lecture on the collapse of Marxist theory. Having already argued that scarcity undermines Marx's vision of superabundance, Shapiro turns to further weaknesses: Marx's failure to anticipate the modern state's capacity to prop up capitalism and prevent the crises he predicted, the absence of any real tendency for the economy-wide rate of profit to fall, and deep incoherence in the labor theory of value. The lecture moves through macro-level critiques before narrowing to micro-level problems in Marxian economics. Shapiro closes by salvaging two legacies worth keeping despite the theory's collapse: Marx's critique of markets as arbitrary distributors of goods and harms, and his power-based argument about freedom. Recorded in Spring 2010, the talk is organized into three chapters moving from introduction to macro theory to micro theory, giving a systematic account of why Marxism failed as prediction even as parts of it survive as critique.