
The Neoclassical Synthesis of Rights and Utility
Yale political science professor Ian Shapiro examines John Stuart Mill's attempt to reconcile individual rights with utilitarian ethics, part of his Moral Foundations of Politics course. The lecture traces how Mill's neoclassical utilitarianism departs from Jeremy Bentham's classical version, centering on the harm principle, which permits interference with individual liberty only to prevent harm to others. Shapiro walks through Mill's four arguments for freedom of speech, grounded in the idea that open argument leads society toward truth, and situates Mill's fallibilism against earlier Enlightenment confidence in reason. The lecture then turns critical, identifying inconsistencies in how Mill applies his own harm principle, particularly cases where he seems to overlook certain harms to others. Shapiro proposes a two-step reading of Mill to resolve this tension. Recorded in Spring 2010, the lecture runs just over forty minutes and is chaptered into Mill's biography, the free speech arguments, and the problems with defining harm.