
Contemporary Communitarianism (I)
Ian Shapiro continues his Yale course Moral Foundations of Politics with a lecture on communitarian critiques of Enlightenment liberalism. Having covered traditionalist conservatism in the prior session, Shapiro turns to Alasdair MacIntyre, alongside a brief mention of Richard Rorty's rejection of ground-up philosophical justification. He traces two symptoms MacIntyre diagnoses in post-Enlightenment moral thought: the rise of emotivism, in which moral judgments collapse into subjective preference, and the triumph of instrumentalism, which severs means from ends and abandons teleology as a response to pluralism. The lecture closes by introducing MacIntyre's key concepts of practices and virtues, setting up the ethical alternative communitarians propose to Enlightenment rationalism. Recorded in Spring 2010, the talk runs about fifty minutes and is organized into chapters covering MacIntyre's intellectual context, his critique of modern moral discourse, and his foundational vocabulary of virtue ethics.