
Democratic Justice: Theory
Ian Shapiro continues his Yale course The Moral Foundations of Politics with a lecture on democracy and justice. He returns to Schumpeter's minimalist definition of democracy, showing that once operationalized as a two turnover test it turns out to be more demanding than it first appears. Shapiro examines why people under unjust regimes often demand democracy, then grow disillusioned when democratic governments fail to deliver justice, while societies simultaneously resist justice schemes imposed without democratic legitimacy. He proposes a theory of democratic justice built on four features: a broad conception of politics, a semi-contextual approach, a distinction between superordinate and subordinate goods, and two dimensions of democracy, namely collective self-government grounded in the principle of affected interest and institutionalized opposition with a presumption against hierarchy. The lecture is divided into three chapters covering expectations of democracy, the concept of democratic justice, and the general argument for synthesizing the two.