
Compensation versus Redistribution
Ian Shapiro continues Yale's Moral Foundations of Politics course with a lecture on Robert Nozick's theory of justice. He walks through Nozick's threefold framework of justice in acquisition, justice in transfer, and rectification of past injustices, explaining how voluntary transactions inevitably disrupt any initial distribution, since liberty upsets patterns. The lecture examines why Nozick wants to keep government redistribution to a minimum, given pluralism about what counts as a fair pattern, and how he distinguishes this from compensation, a backward looking remedy aimed at making harmed individuals whole rather than imposing a social pattern. Shapiro presses on the unresolved problem of how far back rectification must reach. Recorded in Spring 2010, the lecture runs about 46 minutes and is divided into chapters covering the components of Nozickian justice, acquisition and transfer, and compensation as rectification.