
Democracy and Majority Rule (I)
Ian Shapiro opens the third section of his Yale course Moral Foundations of Politics, turning from rights and welfare to democracy itself. He argues democracy best fulfills the Enlightenment's twin commitments to individual rights and objective knowledge, and notes that the democratic tradition was shaped as much by its critics as its champions. The lecture moves through Plato's suspicion of majority rule, Tocqueville's fear of majority tyranny, and Madison's response in the Federalist Papers, where factions are checked through an extended republic and constitutional veto points rather than eliminated outright. Shapiro connects these arguments to the structure of American government, tracing how checks and balances were designed to blunt factionalism without abandoning popular rule. Chapters move from fear of majority tyranny to Madison's constitutional design to veto points as institutional solutions. Recorded in Spring 2010, the lecture is a close reading of founding-era political theory rather than a survey.