
Contemporary Communitarianism (II)
Ian Shapiro continues his Yale course Moral Foundations of Politics with a lecture on Alasdair MacIntyre's Aristotelian account of human psychology. Shapiro lays out its two features: that human nature is inherently teleological, and that human behavior is other-directed, with happiness conditioned on feeling valued by someone one values. He traces MacIntyre's distinction between an untutored, raw condition and the realization of one's telos, and explains why MacIntyre thinks ethics cannot be deduced from facts about human nature, the core of his critique of the Enlightenment project. The lecture also covers MacIntyre's partial concession to Enlightenment thinking, that humans can reason critically about purposes, but only from within an inherited system of norms. Chapters move from the Aristotelian framework through the critique of Enlightenment rationalism to MacIntyre's own prescription. Recorded in Spring 2010 as part of the PLSC 118 series.