
The Marxian Challenge
Ian Shapiro continues his Yale course Moral Foundations of Politics with a lecture on Marx as an Enlightenment thinker rather than a simple critic of capitalism. Shapiro argues that Marx believed capitalism would self-destruct through its own economic logic and give way to socialism, and that Marx's egalitarianism aimed at universal freedom, not its abolition. He traces Marx's debt to Locke's workmanship ideal and to classical economists Adam Smith and David Ricardo, building toward Marx's labor theory of value. The lecture works through natural versus market prices, use-value and exchange value, the commodification of labor, and alienation, ending on the puzzle Marx inherited from classical political economy: if equivalents exchange for equivalents in the market, where does profit actually come from. Chapters cover Marx and the Enlightenment, his intellectual biography, and the project of classical political economy. Recorded in Spring 2010 as part of Shapiro's full course on political theory.